My confusion and distress before, on and after Sept 11.

It’s often asked what were you doing on September 11. I remember the day well. I had come out of the hallway and heard the TV say a plane had flown into the twin towers. Without giving it much thought – I continued into the kitchen to make myself a cuppa and snack. Sitting on the couch I was in shock as I watched the events of the day unfold before me.

During the day I became distressed with the destruction and loss of life that was being reported. My heart was crying out Lord have mercy! In the days and weeks that followed, like many other Australians our conversations were based around the horrific acts of destruction and loss. They were filled with tales of awe as we spoke about the heroic acts that saved more lives from being lost, the rescue teams, every one pitching together to help each other.

Yet – I was also questioning was Gods hand of judgement against America and the world through, in and over this destruction. A few short weeks before I had seen a documentary about Afghanistan and how the Taliban had continued its tribal purging and pushed over 2 million Afghanistan people into a refugee camp into a border of Pakistan. The documentary showed that neither Pakistan nor the Taliban would allow aid of any kind into this camp of 2 million people and the little aid that was there had to be smuggled in.

I fell to the floor with an intense intercessory pain where I was begging the Lord to do something for these people. Surely I cried out to the Lord, its not your intention to allow these people to die. For you to allow 2 million people to die. This intercessory burden was on me for a number of weeks and it lifted a few days before Sept 11 and I felt the Lord whisper into my inner being that he was going to help those people.

And shortly after Sept 11 the Bush administration said they were going to go into Afghanistan by force, that they would take human aid into that keep and bring freedom to those 2 million people held in captivity. I can’t imagine what 2 million people look like. What does that number of people living in sub prime conditions look like? Little food, little water, little shelter. But they were and so over the next weeks and months we watched as armed forces and the united nations moved into that camp bringing a measure of relief and sustenance into the lives of those people.

Sept 11 raises more questions for me than I have answers. The world could have stepped in and helped those people before Sept 11 happened. If they did, would the twin towers episode have happened. Would the world powers have stepped in and helped those 2 million people if the attacks on Sept 11 never happened and that day was a normal day like any other – for those living in stable nations. Did God allow Sept 11 to happen, was it his hand of judgement on the nations – for certainly the twin towers represent globalisation.

These are questions that I don’t know how to answer and indeed are questions that I’m not sure I really want to answer. And indeed in trying to answer any of these questions without sounding glib is impossible. And so these questions remain hanging, with no real answers as to why. And the gnawing of confusion, hurt and pain lingers on.

Today its September 11 in Australia. I propose that we not only remember Sept 11 as a day of remembering what happened in America. I propose that its a day that we remember all through out the world who are suffering from the affects of war and terrorism. That today is a day where we reflect that war and terrorism is no longer out of sight and out of mind; rather that on a global scale we too, have been and are and will continue to be affected by it. ..and may the question always be with us, what is happening elsewhere in the world and what can we do to help in those situations.

And within this framework I say…let us all pray for all, for all have been affected.

About Craig Benno

I'm an average aussie guy who has lived perhaps a not so average life.
This entry was posted in Sept 11 and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to My confusion and distress before, on and after Sept 11.

  1. tildeb says:

    And I say let us look with open eyes how religion just as easily empowers atrocity in the name of piousness. Without absolute submission to their religious beliefs, none of those 16 would have tried to fly planes into buildings and shows that there is no way to differentiate between religious belief and delusion.

  2. Pingback: Confusion, pain and unanswered questions of Sept 11 | Unsettled Christianity

  3. Craig Benno says:

    Tildeb…its been proven that its not religion that starts the majority of wars…. what are your thoughts about the tribalism of the Taliban who were hunting down and exterminating their fellow muslims…..certainly it had nothing to do with religious beliefs at all.

    • tildeb says:

      Tribalism? Craig, the taliban is wahhabism in action. This is the same wahhabism of Saudi Arabia, funded by oil profits and exported around the world in many forms – from the terrorism of al qaeda to sharia courts, from CDs and DVDs and pamphlets about this literal reading of the koran to printing high gloss multi-coloured biology textbooks to refute evolution. This IS the root of islamicism and it is religion through and through. It treats Enlightenment values and principles as pornography and deals with the West as a mortal enemy. Many of the adherents will also kill anyone who is not a true muslim as easily a kafir, using the same reasoning: it is so commanded in the koran, which is as true for an islamicist as biblical scripture is for you and used identically to justify atrocities as you use scripture to justify compassion. There is no difference in reasoning between you: faith. You just express it differently.

      • Craig Benno says:

        Would you consider the response of America or the West to be a religious response. Certainly that is how many Muslims see it in Islamic countries….the truth is, its a cultural war and not a religious one.

      • tildeb says:

        Oh yes, it is culture that has the hijackers calling out ‘god is great’ is when they crash into buildings. It is culture that influences an army psychiatrist to open fire on his fellow soldiers in Fort Hood. It is culture that has taliban firing rocket grenades into monuments. Yada, yada, yada… always anything BUT religion to the apologists under the phrase ‘The truth is…’

        Well, the truth is that perhaps it’s time more people started listening to those who carry out these atrocities and believe them when they say they do this to honour their devotion and submission to god. It’s not culture that motivates religious killing as more than a third of British born affluent, university educated muslims say they excuse; it’s in defense of their religion – not culture – where they say it’s allowable. That’s not me saying it is so; it is muslims who say they do so for their faith, and this is played out around the world. That you wish it were entirely culture does not make it true, although I admit culture is certainly an important influence in many human endeavors.

        As for the response, yes, religion plays its role here too. When Bush used the term ‘crusade’ he made it clear that he saw his response as pleasing to god. So, too, did Blair. Religious belief poisons everything, although a military response to Afghanistan’s aid and comfort to al qaeda guaranteed a war. But it’s tough to bomb a stone-age people who believe in stone age religion back to the stone age. What was needed was a dismantling of religion in the public domain and the establishment of a secular liberal democracy. This was never attempted because too many people saw it as colonialism rather than a cleansing of ignorance and superstition from public policy. But how can our public support what is necessary when too many of us won’t even recognize religion as a fundamental problem in the public domain?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s